Scottish Sunday

Government pregnancy-reduction plan is about stopping lower classes breeding, claims expert

By Sarah-Kate Templeton, Health Editor

The government's plan to cut teenage pregnancy in poor areas 'has elements of eugenics', according to a leading sociologist.

Frank Furedi, professor of sociology at the University of Kent at Canterbury and the author of the bestseller Paranoid Parenting, says New Labour and Conservative governments' 'obsession' with reducing teenage pregnancy is driven by a desire to prevent the lower social classes from breeding.

'Now and again there are policies that have eugenic elements,' Furedi told the Scottish Sunday. 'Our government's policy on teenage pregnancy has a eugenic element -- it is really about preventing working-class girls from having children. To some extent, this is eugenics because it is social engineering. If you look at the statistics, middle-class girls from nice families do not have kids when they are teenagers. Teenage pregnancy can be seen as working-class girls having kids and depending on the welfare state.'

The class element and the eugenics debate

In Professor Furedi's view, the focus on teenage pregnancy is an unfair attempt to control the reproductive choices of working-class girls. He argues that the government's concern stems from a belief that the 'wrong type of people are breeding'. While he acknowledges that teenage years are biologically the best age for childbearing, he asserts that policies targeted at reducing teenage pregnancy disproportionately impact the deprived sections of society.

Moreover, Professor Furedi raises objections to the use of contraceptive implants and injections to prevent teenage pregnancy. He expresses concern about pressuring young women into undergoing long-term contraceptive methods, arguing that they should have the freedom to make their own choices about their bodies and reproduction.

Controversy surrounding contraceptive injections

Research conducted on the contraceptive injection, Depo-Provera, suggests that it is primarily given to single and unemployed women. Dr Rosemary Barrett, a GP at Rutherglen Health Centre in Glasgow, believes that the injection is being promoted as a cheap solution to prevent deprived single mothers from becoming pregnant. She notes an increase in the number of teenagers being put on the injection, indicating a potential 'hard sell.'

Susan Stewart, director of family planning organization FPA Scotland, acknowledges that policies aimed at reducing teenage pregnancy often target the poor. However, she emphasizes that it is not in the best interests of deprived women to have children at a young age, as it can negatively impact their education and perpetuate cycles of deprivation.

Government Teenage Pregnancy Policies and Their Impact

The concerns and criticisms raised by Professor Frank Furedi highlight the debate surrounding government policies aimed at reducing teenage pregnancy. While the intention behind these policies is to promote education and better opportunities for young women, there is a need for a more nuanced approach that considers the unique circumstances and choices of individuals from all social backgrounds.

The key issue is striking a balance between promoting reproductive autonomy and ensuring individuals have access to necessary information and resources to make informed choices. This debate invites further exploration into the role of government intervention in personal reproductive decisions and calls for a comprehensive evaluation of the impact of policies to adequately address the complex issue of teenage pregnancy.

Hotels and Accommodation in Scotland

When planning your visit to Scotland, finding suitable accommodation is essential for a comfortable and enjoyable stay. Scotland offers a wide range of options to cater to different preferences and budgets. Whether you're looking for luxury hotels, cozy bed and breakfasts, or self-catering apartments, Scotland has something to suit every traveler's needs.

In the major cities like Edinburgh and Glasgow, you'll find a plethora of hotels ranging from elegant boutique accommodations to internationally renowned luxury establishments. These hotels often provide top-notch amenities, including spas, fine dining restaurants, and stunning views of the city or countryside. Many also offer convenient locations near popular attractions and transportation hubs.

If you prefer a more intimate and personalized experience, Scotland's bed and breakfasts are a fantastic choice. These charming establishments are usually family-owned and offer cozy rooms with a homely atmosphere. Wake up to a traditional Scottish breakfast before setting out to explore the natural beauty and historical sites that await you.

If you're traveling with a group or prefer the flexibility of self-catering, Scotland has plenty of self-catering apartments and holiday homes available. These accommodations allow you to create your own schedule and make yourself at home while enjoying the sights and sounds of Scotland's stunning landscapes.

When booking your accommodation, consider factors such as location, amenities, and reviews from previous guests. Many websites offer user-friendly booking platforms that allow you to compare prices, read reviews, and make secure reservations.

Remember to book your accommodation well in advance, especially during peak travel seasons, to secure your preferred choice and avoid disappointment. With the wide range of options available in Scotland, you're sure to find the perfect place to rest and recharge during your visit.